US President Barack Obama has welcomed the approval by Congress of measures
that would discourage US companies from "shipping jobs overseas" although
Republicans are warning that the bill is yet another example of the Obama administration's
anti-business policies which will ultimately stifle economic growth.
The Education Jobs and Medicaid Assistance Act was sent to the President's
desk on August 10 after the House of Representatives, returning specially from its summer
recess, approved the legislation by a vote of 247 to 161. The bill makes provision
for USD10bn in funding to state governments to meet the cost of teacher salaries
and an additional USD16.1bn to help them meet health funding shortfalls. According
to House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, the bill will save 161,000 teacher jobs while
the Medicaid funding will help prevent state governments from laying off more
than 150,000 police officers, firefighters and other vital community posts. However,
Rep. Dave Camp, the senior Republican on the House Ways and Means Committee,
is of the view that the international tax offsets will actually destroy more
than 140,000 private sector jobs by putting in place almost USD10bn in permanent
tax hikes on US multinationals.
"Democrats suggest the state and local government bailout bill... will
temporarily 'save' certain government jobs. But what they won’t tell you
is that the USD9.6bn in permanent tax hikes they would impose to 'pay
for' that extension of stimulus would destroy over 141,000 private sector
jobs. That would be on top of the 2.5m private sector jobs already eliminated
in the wake of their 2009 stimulus plan," Camp said.
Included in the bill are rules to prevent splitting foreign tax credits from
the income to which they relate. This provision would implement a matching rule
that suspends the recognition of foreign tax credits until the related foreign
income is taken into account for taxing purposes in the US. This provision
would apply to all split foreign taxes claimed by taxpayers after the date of
introduction, and, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation (JCT), would
increase company taxes by USD4.25bn over 10 years.
An additional provision would prohibit taxpayers from claiming the foreign tax credit
with regard to foreign income that is never subject to US taxation because of
a covered asset acquisition. The legislation would apply to related party transactions
occurring after the date of introduction. The JCT estimates that this measure
would raise USD3.64bn in tax over ten years.
Another measure would limit the amount of foreign tax credits that may be claimed
on a deemed dividend under section 956 of the Internal Revenue Code to the amount
that would have been allowed with respect to an actual dividend. According to
JCT, this provision would increase taxes by USD704m over 10 years.
The legislation also terminates the '80/20' rule that excludes a
corporation with gross income of at least 80% from a foreign source and
attributable to foreign trade or business during a three-year period from a
30% withholding tax. Some corporations that meet specific requirements and are
not abusing the '80/20' company rules may receive relief. This provision
would increase taxes by USD153m over ten years, the JCT says.
Other measures would: eliminate a tax planning technique that allows foreign-based
multinationals (e.g. a foreign-based company that owns a US company, and that
US company owns a foreign subsidiary) earnings to bypass the US tax system;
prevent taxpayers from using certain techniques to minimize the amount of foreign
source interest expense, which has the effect of boosting foreign source income
– thus allowing taxpayer to utilize more foreign tax credits; and eliminate
the ability of recipients of the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) to receive
advanced payments throughout the year by having their payments of withheld income
reduced by their employer.
While President Obama said that it is now up to the states to get their fiscal
houses in order, he argued that Congress and the administration could not "stand
by and do nothing while pink slips are given to the men and women who educate
our children or keep our communities safe."
Obama claims that the bill will not add to the federal deficit because it is
"fully paid for, in part by closing tax loopholes that encourage corporations
to ship American jobs overseas." But Republican Congressman Geoff Davis suggested that the bill "somehow
managed to combine three major disturbing themes of Washington Democrats’
agenda – spend money we do not have, a bailout with taxpayer dollars,
and job killing tax increases – into one USD26bn bill."
“We all agree that our children deserve an education system that can
equip the next generation of workers and entrepreneurs, but more spending alone
will not keep this promise to our children any better than the last trillion
dollars of government stimulus ‘created’ jobs," he commented.
"In fact, it could destroy another 141,000 private sector jobs as a result
of the tax increases included in the bill."