To
receive our free monthly network newsletter enter your
email address below:
ADVERTISE!
Our sites have more than 200,000 highly targeted visitors
every month. With cost-effective marketing solutions to suit
any budget, we feel confident that we can deliver the results
you need.
>
Information provided on this site is for general guidance only and
is often simplified. Actual IRS procedures are complex, and taxpayers
should obtain professional assistance or use IRS sources for complete
information.
Court To Reconsider Whistleblower Tax Case,
by Glen Shapiro, LawAndTax-News.com, Washington 28 August 2007
Last week attorneys for whistleblower Marrita Murphy asked a US court to reconsider
its decision that her award for emotional distress should be taxable, itself
a reversal of an earlier decision in her favour.
Ms Murphy's attorneys David Colapinto and Stephen Kohn have asked the full
US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit to reconsider a July
decision by a three-judge panel that held that the IRS can tax damage awards
based solely on compensating victims who suffer personal injuries, claiming
that Congress intended to amend the tax code “by implication” to
tax personal injury damages under its authority to create an excise tax on people
who use the courts to vindicate their rights. But a year earlier, the same panel
in the same case held that such taxes were unconstitutional, as compensation
for a documented "loss" was not "income" subject to the
tax code.
Marrita Murphy had received $70,000 compensation after having filed a complaint
with the Labor Department against her former employer. She paid taxes on the
award but later filed an amended return asking for a refund, which the IRS rejected.
"The Court's reversal stands reality on its head," said Mr Colapinto.
“This case marks the first time that a court has interpreted the gross
‘income’ statute, 26 U.S.C. § 61(a), to be amended ‘by
implication’ to create a tax not expressly enacted by Congress. Additionally,
this is the first time that any court has construed the tax code to imply an
“excise tax” on the ‘privilege’ of utilizing the ‘legal
system’ to vindicate a federal statutory right."
"When whistleblowers suffer retaliation, they do not 'sell' their mental
health. If people are injured in a car accident, they do not 'sell' their arms
and legs. These are real human losses, and compensation to restore that human
loss was never intended to be 'income' under our Constitution or the tax code,"
Colapinto said.
Stephen M. Kohn, the President of the National Whistleblower Center and co-counsel
for Ms. Murphy, stated: "This decision is a terrible setback for all victims
of civil rights abuses. Congress did not pass a special tax demanding payment
from people who use the legal system to prevent retaliation against whistleblowers.
It was error for the Court to imply such a tax. This decision threatens fundamental
human rights, including access to the courts."
One of the web's
largest and most authoritative business and investment information
sources. Alongside topical, daily news on worldwide
tax developments, you can receive weekly newswires or
access up-to-date intelligence
reports on a range of legal, tax and investment subjects.
Our 16 constantly
updated intelligence reports cover every important aspect
of 'offshore' and international tax-planning in depth, including
banking secrecy, the EU's savings tax directive, offshore
funds, e-commerce, offshore gaming and transfer pricing. Reports
are available for immediate downloading or as subscription
services with news pages.
New On The Network Today
This feed is published daily with selected new or updated
content from across our network. For a list of network sites, many of
which feature daily news, see below.
Providing essential tax news and information for globally
mobile artists, contractors, entrepreneurs, professionals, small businesses,
sportspersons and entertainers.
Lowtax Network Sites
Lowtax Network Portal:
'Low-tax' business and investment in the top 50 jurisdictions covered in
exceptional detail.
Tax News: Global
tax news, continuously updated through the day.
Law & Tax
News: Daily news and background data on tax and legal developments
for international business.
Offshore-e-com:
A topical guide to offshore e-commerce focused on tax and regulation.
Lowtax Library:
One of the web's largest and most authoritative business and investment
information sources.
US Tax Network:
The resource for free online US taxation information, covering: corporate
tax, individual tax, international tax, expatriates, sales and e-commerce
tax, investment tax.
NEW! Personal
Business Tax Guide: Providing essential tax news and information
on business for contractors, entrepreneurs, professionals, small businesses,
artists, sportspersons and entertainers.
IMPORTANT NOTICE:
THE LOWTAX NETWORK has taken reasonable care in sourcing and presenting
the information contained on this site, but accepts no responsibility
for any financial or other loss or damage that may result from its use.
In particular, users of the site are advised to take appropriate professional
advice before committing themselves to involvement in offshore jurisdictions,
offshore trusts or offshore investments. All materials on this site copyright
The Lowtax Network 1999 - 2010.
All content on this
site has been provided by BSIRN.